ERC Advisor: How to Choose the Right Expert to Maximize Your Employee Retention Credit

By Eric Tuthill, CPA

DOWNLOAD THE WHITE PAPER

Complex Tax Credit & Incentive Matters: What Your Business Needs to Know

    Many businesses left significant money on the table during the pandemic—and some still can claim it. An erc advisor specializes in helping eligible employers navigate the complex employee retention credit program, a government-backed tax credit initiative designed to help businesses retain employees during the COVID-19 pandemic. Many businesses and self-employed individuals are not aware of their eligibility for the ERC program, missing out on valuable benefits. Experienced advisors have already secured millions in ERC stimulus funds for clients, ensuring you capture every dollar while staying compliant with IRS requirements.

    Table of Contents

    What an ERC Advisor Does (and Why You Need One Now)

    An Employee Retention Credit (ERC) advisor is a specialized tax professional who manages the end-to-end process of claiming this refundable tax credit for eligible businesses. These experts help companies correctly claim the employee retention credit erc, especially retroactively through Form 941-X amendments, serving as a trusted advisor throughout the process.

    • Interprets complex IRS guidance: Advisors navigate complex IRS regulations including Notice 2021-20, 2021-23, and 2021-49, plus CARES Act rules to determine your eligibility requirements, and provide additional information by referencing official IRS notices or FAQ resources to clarify complex topics.
    • Calculates maximum credits: For 2020, eligible employers can receive a refundable tax credit of up to $5,000 per employee, while for the first three quarters of 2021, the credit increases to up to $7,000 per employee per quarter, totaling up to $26,000 per employee.
    • Meets critical deadlines: The deadline for 2021 ERC claims is April 15, 2025—acting now is essential.
    • Ensures audit-readiness: Professionals assist with IRS inquiries and provide audit defense concerning ERC claims, preparing documentation that withstands scrutiny rather than “file and hope.” The correct forms and instructions depend on your specific organization and tax period.
    • Prepares IRS filings independently: Advisors can prepare and file your ERC claims directly with the IRS, without involving your payroll company in the process.
    • Identifies qualified wages: Advisors calculate the exact value of the ERC by identifying qualified wages and health plan expenses specific to your circumstances.
    A professional tax advisor is reviewing documents with a small business owner, discussing eligibility requirements for the employee retention tax credit and how it could benefit their business. The advisor is providing guidance on maximizing potential tax refunds and ensuring compliance with IRS regulations.

    Key ERC Rules and Deadlines You Must Understand (2020–2025)

    Understanding the foundational rules helps you see what your trusted erc advisor will work with. The Employee Retention Credit (ERC) was established by the CARES Act to incentivize businesses to keep employees on payroll during the COVID-19 pandemic and was later expanded under the american rescue plan act.

    • 2020 ERC basics: 50% tax credit on up to $10,000 in qualified wages per employee for the entire year (March 13, 2020–December 31, 2020), yielding a maximum erc of $5,000 per employee. The gross receipt reduction criteria for 2020 require a 50% decline compared to the same quarter in 2019.
    • 2021 ERC basics: 70% credit on up to $10,000 in paid qualified wages per employee per quarter for Q1, Q2, and Q3 2021—up to $21,000 per employee that year. The gross receipt reduction criteria for 2021 require only a 20% decline compared to the same quarter in 2019.
    • Total potential: Up to $26,000 per employee combined, though actual amounts depend on employee count, wages paid, and eligibility tests.
    • Coverage period: Eligible employers must have paid qualified wages to some or all employees after March 12, 2020, and before January 1, 2022. Recovery startup businesses (entities starting after February 15, 2020, with under $1 million in average gross receipts) may claim through Q4 2021.
    • Filing mechanics: To claim the Employee Retention Credit, eligible businesses must file adjusted employment tax returns, such as Form 941-X, to claim the credit for prior quarters.
    • PPP interaction: Wages used for Paycheck Protection Program forgiveness cannot be double-counted for ERC. When filing Form 941-X to claim the ERC, employers must reduce their deduction for wages by the amount of the credit claimed for that same tax period, which may require amending their income tax return.

    Do You Still Qualify? Core ERC Eligibility Tests an Advisor Will Review

    With changing rules and aggressive marketing creating confusion, here’s the checklist your advisor uses to determine if your business qualifies.

    • Gross receipts test (2020): Businesses that experienced a decline in gross receipts of 50% compared to the same quarter in 2019 may qualify for the Employee Retention Credit. Eligibility continues until receipts recover above 80% of 2019 levels
    • Gross receipts test (2021): Only a 20% decline versus the same 2019 quarter is required, with an alternative prior-quarter election available
    • Partial suspension test: Employers can qualify if their business experienced a full or partial suspension of operations due to government orders related to COVID-19 during any quarter. This includes restaurants facing indoor dining bans, gyms under closure mandates, and medical offices halting elective procedures
    • Supply chain disruptions: A possible eligibility path, but IRS scrutiny is high—documentation must tie directly to specific government orders affecting your suppliers
    • Recovery startup businesses: Companies starting operations after February 15, 2020, with average annual gross receipts under $1 million, may qualify for Q3 and Q4 2021 ERC up to $50,000 per quarter
    • Aggregation rules: An advisor reviews common ownership across entities and multi-state operations to avoid misapplying thresholds under IRC Section 52

    Both businesses and tax exempt organizations can qualify for the Employee Retention Credit if they meet the required wage payment conditions during the eligible timeframes.

    Advisors perform a detailed analysis and research of a business’s facts and circumstances to determine eligibility, including research into eligibility and potential financial opportunities. By staying current on evolving legislation, advisors can identify missed opportunities for retroactive claims and provide valuable advice on maximizing available benefits.

    Red Flags, IRS Scrutiny, and How a Legitimate ERC Advisor Protects You

    The IRS has increased scrutiny on ERC claims due to rampant fraud, prompting the recommendation for businesses to prepare an Employee Retention Credit Substantiation Report to support their claims.

    Common red flags from scam promoters:

    • “Guaranteed” erc credits without reviewing your payroll data
    • Fees based only on credit size with no substantiation or eligibility memo
    • Unwillingness to sign tax returns under Circular 230
    • Generic “government order” claims without specific legal citations

    Consequences of improper claims: Many businesses that filed ERC claims have reported receiving 10% to 50% less than the amounts they were eligible to receive, leading to ongoing delays in refunds even after 18 months. Improper claims can trigger repayment demands, penalties, and interest.

    Your options if you filed incorrectly: Employers that submitted ineligible ERC claims can avoid future issues such as audits and penalties by withdrawing their claims, even if they have already received a check for the ERC. A qualified advisor can guide this process.

    How credible advisors protect you: They prepare formal eligibility memos, maintain copies of government orders, create contemporaneous documentation, and coordinate with your existing CPA. Ask prospective advisors about their methodology and whether they’ll support you if the IRS issues inquiries. You should also review their website and resource page for additional information about their process.

    How a Professional ERC Advisor Works with Your Business

    Here’s what a typical ERC advisory engagement looks like from first call to tax refund.

    • Initial consultation (15–30 minutes): Gathering basics—industry, 2019–2021 gross receipts, employee counts, PPP use, and major COVID-19 impacts on your operations
    • Detailed eligibility analysis: Review of financials, payroll registers, PPP forgiveness documents, and relevant government orders affecting your locations or supply chain, including verification that you pay the required wages or contributions to qualify for the ERC.
    • Credit calculation: Line-by-line review of qualified wages, health plan costs, owner and family attribution rules, and per-quarter limits with transparent workpapers, ensuring all payment requirements are met to avoid errors or penalties.
    • Claim preparation: They prepare the required Form 941-X and provide instructions for submission to the IRS, coordinating with your tax preparer on necessary income tax return adjustments
    • Substantiation report: Advisors compile substantiation reports to provide a detailed record of eligibility for the ERC. To maximize ERC claims, businesses should consider obtaining an Employee Retention Credit Substantiation Report, which provides documentation to support their eligibility amid increased IRS scrutiny
    • Timeline management: IRS processing can take several months to over a year. A good advisor sets realistic expectations and provides status updates to help taxpayers stay informed throughout the process.

    To get started, request a consultation or review to begin your ERC claim process.

    A small business owner is seen organizing payroll documents and financial records on a desk, highlighting the importance of managing employee retention tax credits and qualified wages for eligible employers. The scene emphasizes the meticulous process of ensuring compliance with IRS requirements and maximizing potential tax refunds through programs like the Employee Retention Credit (ERC).

    Why Choose Our Firm as Your ERC Advisor

    We position ourselves as a dependable, experienced ERC partner emphasizing accuracy, documentation, and client support for many businesses across industries.

    • Proven results: We’ve helped clients across hospitality, healthcare, construction, and professional services identify significant payroll tax credits
    • Deep experience: Our team brings decades of combined federal tax and payroll experience to every engagement
    • Risk-conscious approach: No “one-size-fits-all” templates—individualized eligibility analysis with readiness to stand behind our work if the IRS asks questions
    • Transparent pricing: Success-based fee structure with no surprise add-ons, clearly documented before we begin
    • Collaborative service: We work alongside your existing CPA, bookkeeper, and payroll provider rather than replacing them

    Ready to get started? Schedule your consultation and gather your recent 941s, 2019–2021 P&Ls, and PPP documentation.

    ERC Advisor FAQs

    Here are the most common questions businesses ask before engaging an advisor.

    • Do I still have time to file? Yes—many employers can still amend 2020 and 2021 returns within the three-year statute. The deadline for 2021 ERC claims is April 15, 2025, making now the time to act.
    • Can my regular CPA handle ERC? Many CPAs can, but the program’s complexity means some prefer collaborating with a specialist. A good advisor coordinates with your existing tax professional.
    • What documents will an advisor need? Quarterly payroll reports, Forms 941, PPP forgiveness applications, 2019–2021 financial statements, and any relevant government orders or internal memos about COVID-19 impacts.
    • How are fees typically structured? Common models include contingent fees (percentage of credit), flat fees, or hourly rates. We offer transparent, success-aligned pricing.
    • What if another firm already filed my claim? Many businesses that filed ERC claims have reported receiving 10% to 50% less than the amounts they were eligible for due to inaccuracies in the disbursement process. A new advisor can review for accuracy and help correct prior filings.
    • Will claiming ERC increase my audit risk? Risk comes primarily from unsupported or aggressive claims. A thorough, well-documented file prepared by a qualified advisor is your best protection.

    Conclusion: Next Steps to Secure and Protect Your ERC Refund

    ERC remains a major cash-flow opportunity for eligible businesses, but rules are complex and enforcement is tightening. Self employed individuals and small business owners alike need guidance from companies that understand this program inside and out.

    • Don’t wait: Deadlines for amending 2020 and 2021 payroll returns are here or approaching—leaving money unclaimed benefits no one
    • Choose wisely: Select an advisor focused on both maximum refund and audit-ready documentation
    • Take action now: Contact our team via phone, email, or online form for a no-obligation ERC review. Have your Forms 941, revenue by quarter (2019–2021), and PPP details ready

    We’re here as your long-term tax credit partner—ready to help with future credits and incentives as legislation evolves.

    CTA Work by the Numbers

    $300M+

    Client Tax Credits & Incentives Identified

    200+

    Years Combined Tax Credit & Incentive Experience

    1000+

    Successful Tax Credit & Incentive Studies

    Helping Businesses & CPAs Across the Nation with Specialty Tax Credit Services Since 2014

    Are You Ready to Find Out if You Can Fund Your Future Out of Taxes You May Not Owe?

    Let's Find Out Together...

    Request Your Eligibility Evaluation

    Memberships & Associations

    CPA Friends:

    Sign Up for Our "Tax Credits & Incentives Update" Newsletter to Stay Informed on Changes That May Impact Your Clients